Equipment leasing usually wins when you will replace the asset within 2 to 4 years or need the lowest monthly payment; an equipment loan usually wins when you will keep the asset for its full life and want to own it outright. The exception is the $1-buyout lease, which behaves like a loan in almost every way that matters, including taxes. This page compares all three structures with the same $120,000 machine so you can see where the money goes.
It is a spoke of our equipment financing pillar, which covers rates, down payments and Section 179 in more depth. Select Loan Advisors is an advisory firm, not a lender or lessor, so we have no reason to push you toward one structure over another.
Equipment loan. You borrow to buy. The lender holds a lien on the asset until the last payment, then releases it. You are the owner from day one for tax and accounting purposes.
$1-buyout lease (capital or finance lease). The lessor technically owns the equipment during the term, and you buy it for $1 at the end. Because the buyout is nominal, the IRS and your accountant generally treat it as a purchase: it goes on your balance sheet and you take depreciation, including Section 179 where eligible. Payments are similar to a loan. Lessors use this structure because it is often faster to document and can be easier to approve than a loan.
Fair-market-value (FMV) lease (operating lease). You rent the equipment for a term. At the end you can return it, renew, or buy it at its then-current market value. Payments are lower because you are only paying for the portion of value you use up. You do not own the asset, so you generally deduct the lease payments as an operating expense rather than depreciating the equipment.
Amounts, rates and terms shown are illustrative examples, not an offer or a quote. Select Loan Advisors is not a lender; funding partners set all terms. See how we're compensated.
Assume a $120,000 piece of equipment, an illustrative 11% rate on the loan and $1-buyout lease, an illustrative 9% implicit rate on the FMV lease (lessors often price these lower because they keep the residual), and a 36-month FMV term with a 20% residual.
| Equipment loan (60 mo, 10% down) | $1-buyout lease (60 mo, $0 down) | FMV lease (36 mo, 20% residual) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash at signing | $12,000 down | Usually first payment, sometimes first and last | Usually first payment |
| Monthly payment | about $2,348 on $108,000 | about $2,609 on $120,000 | about $3,233 |
| Total paid over term | about $152,891 including down payment | about $156,545 | about $116,380 |
| Own it at the end? | Yes | Yes, for $1 | No; buy for about $24,000, renew, or return |
| Cost to own at end of term | about $152,891 | about $156,546 | about $140,380 if you buy at the 20% residual |
| Year-one tax treatment | Depreciate or expense the asset (Section 179 / bonus, if eligible) | Same as a loan, generally | Deduct payments as an expense, generally |
| Balance sheet | Asset and liability | Asset and liability | Lease liability under current accounting standards; ask your CPA |
Three things jump out. The FMV lease has the highest monthly payment here because the term is shortest, not because leasing is expensive; stretch it to 60 months and the payment drops to roughly $2,173. The $1-buyout lease costs a little more than the loan because nothing was put down. And the FMV lease is the cheapest path to ownership only if the residual is honest; if the lessor sets the buyout at market value and the market is strong, you could pay more than the illustrative $24,000.
A dentist is buying a $60,000 digital imaging unit. The manufacturer typically releases a new model every 3 to 4 years, and the practice plans to upgrade when that happens.
For this practice, the FMV lease fits the upgrade cycle. For a general contractor buying a skid steer they expect to run for a decade, the loan or $1-buyout lease fits better. The equipment tells you the answer more often than the financing does.
We take one application, run a soft credit pull, and go to the funding partners most likely to say yes, including equipment lenders and lessors. You see loan and lease offers side by side with the implicit rate and total cost calculated, not just the monthly payment. There is no fee for our service; funding partners pay us when a deal closes. The details are on our pages about how business loan brokers work and how do business loan brokers get paid.
Over the full life of an asset you keep, financing is almost always cheaper because you stop paying once the loan is done. Over a short holding period, an FMV lease is usually cheaper because you only pay for the value you use and avoid selling a used asset. Compare total cost over the number of years you will actually use the equipment, not the monthly payment alone.
A $1-buyout lease ends with you owning the equipment for a nominal dollar; it is structured and generally taxed like a purchase, with payments close to a loan. A fair-market-value lease ends with the option to return the equipment, renew, or buy it at its then-current market value; payments are lower and are generally deducted as an operating expense. Ownership and tax treatment are the key differences.
Generally only on a lease that is treated as a purchase for tax purposes, such as a $1-buyout or similar capital lease. On a true FMV or operating lease, the lessor owns the asset and takes depreciation; you deduct your lease payments instead. For tax years beginning in 2026 the Section 179 limit is $2,560,000 per IRS Publication 946. Confirm the treatment of your specific lease with your CPA.
Usually not in the traditional sense. Most leases require the first payment, and sometimes the first and last, at signing. Newer businesses or weaker credit files may be asked for a larger security deposit or several months of advance rentals. Loans, by contrast, often require 0% to 20% down but let you use a larger down payment to lower the rate.
On a $1-buyout lease, you pay $1 and receive title. On an FMV lease, you choose to return the equipment (subject to return conditions and shipping), renew month to month or for a new term, or buy it at fair market value. Many leases auto-renew if you miss the notice window, often 60 to 120 days before the end, so mark that date when you sign.
Often, yes. Because the lessor keeps title, some lessors will approve newer businesses or credit scores in the low 600s that an equipment lender would decline, though the implicit rate and deposit will be higher. If your file is strong, a loan or $1-buyout lease will typically price lower. We show both when both are available.
If you already have a quote for the equipment, an advisor can show you loan and lease offers side by side, usually the same business day. If you are not sure which structure fits, start with our equipment financing guide or simply ask; we will tell you which one we would choose in your position.
Check My Options →